April 1950 was the first time that Diocese of Buffalo awarded the newly created Boy Scout Pelican award. The Most Rev. John F O’Hara (yes the high school was named in honor of him) presented the award at St. Joseph New Cathedral.
The men receiving this award were:
- Buffalo Council: William F Payne, George Weinfurter, Charles F. Eichhorn, John M Gavin and William Robillard
- Senecal Council: Dr. James L. Hayes (Olean)
- Genesee Council: Francis J. Guppenberger (Batavia)
- Niagara Frontier Council: John B. LaMunsch (Niagara Falls)
- Chautauqua County Council: Bernard G. Dougherty (Dunkirk)
- Lewiston Trail Council: William J. Madden (Lockport)
153 boys received the Ad Altare Dei Award. This award was started in 1926 to recognize Roman Catholic alter boys and is still awarded today.